Thursday, August 12, 2010

On why I hate women's ministry...

So hate is a strong word. Maybe I should say strongly dislike. Maybe that is a more appropriate way to start this post. Let's try again: "On why I strongly dislike women's ministry." That's better. Less offensive I think.

I was recently sitting in Nebraska with Chad's mom and sister and we were discussing women's ministry. Now, these two women are some of the more conservative Christian women I've met. That's why I was super surprised to hear them say how much they disliked most women's ministry. They talked of how they hated women's retreats and loathed many of the Christian books written by women. Well, this sparked my interest, for I too have long avoided anything labeled, "Women's Ministry." Why such an aversion you may ask?

To be fair, there are some women I can tolerate and actually enjoy hearing. It seems that in comparison to the hundreds of other ones I dislike, this number is very small. Having attended a Christian college, I was subject to ministers from all over the place. Most of the time when the women's meeting would roll around it would be these middle aged women who would get up in front of us college kids and tell us that if we did A, B, C and D, in that order that we too could have the hot husband, the 3 gorgeous kids and a thriving career. They say things like, "my darlings" and use words like, "estrogen, hormones, and submission". That last word left me horrified for years! The truth is that these women are OUT OF TOUCH. I even went to one meeting where the whole thing just talked about proper etiquette when hosting people and how if we want to run with kings and queens, that we have to act like Christian royalty.

I think I just threw up in my mouth a little bit.

I've recently started in a women's group. I know I will love the content of the study. It's the person on the screen presenting the information that I have to get past. I don't relate. I don't have common ground. I feel like there is this entire generation of young women who were all raised in such a different world than our parents were. I can't relate to the women on stage who tells me her every dream was just to be a housewife and a mother. I'm sure some people have those dreams and she totally ministers to them. I'm just not that woman.

I have dreams of being a great mother and an amazing home manager...but I also want to pursue the giftings and dreams God has given me outside the home. And please don't tell me, as was told to me on several occasions, "God can use those giftings in the home in a more appropriate way than in the workplace."

Ha!

That truly makes me laugh. Not that I don't think my strengths are to be used in the home, because I KNOW they are. In addition to the home, I see evidence in the Bible of women using their strengths outside the home. Maybe these women who are so opposed to a strong working woman should read Proverbs 31 again with a little more attention to verse 16-31. I see her buying fields and doing business in the marketplace while raising up children and caring for her home.

That is the kind of woman I want to be and I think I'm becoming. I've had at least 3 different conversations lately with women who, like me, can't stand the way Christian women are portrayed. They too wish there was some authenticity to the ministry going on.

I say, we young Christian women need to start the trend with this. We need to stop filtering our experiences to ensure they are pretty and neat and we need to get real with each other and with God. When I think about the generation gap between me and the generation above me and then I consider that there is such a great chasm forming between me and the next generation, it scares me. This younger generation is nothing if not real. There is no pretense. You can't tell these young people to just "Kiss Dating Goodbye" when their generation is having sex at a staggeringly young age. How will they relate with us if we aren't genuine about our mistakes, our hurts, our struggles???

My goal in the next few weeks is to get real. I want to be open about what I'm learning and how I'm failing. I want to share real life with others instead of trying to make it so perfect. When life is good and I'm winning in areas, I want to be able to rejoice about it. When life just sucks, I want to be real about it. I can't figure out why being a Christian mean being fake and pretending like life is perfect. I get walking in faith and focusing on the blessings of God, but haven't we all been in the situation before where you just can't see the blessings in the midst of the trial? Maybe a little honesty in that area would go a long way in helping others get through the trial and on to the good stuff.

I think I'm glad that not many people read my blog at this point because I think some of the things I said are offensive. It legitimately how I believe though, so no apologies. I think I needed some authenticity in my life right now, so there you go!

2 comments:

Dominika said...

I'm with you! It's all good to sugar coat stuff and make everything pretty as you put it but that's not life. Like a line in a movie, life's dirty. I think it's not just women though that have to get real...men do too. Life is a journey filled with good and bad things, we have to be able to embrace all of it so that not only we can learn from it but future generations can too :o)

Leslie said...

Wow! I love the challenge. I've been struggling a lot with being my true authentic self. Instead, I find myself feeling pressured to be one of "those" Christian women. It feels so foreign to me and when I realize that there is a different person trapped inside this robotic type body, it kind of freaks me out. Keep us posted on the journey of being more authentic!